Discussion about this post

User's avatar
HSH's avatar

Excellent assessment. To take it to the next step, consider the likely outcomes of your presented options. By accepting a cease fire deal (assuming the unlikely Hamas cooperation), I suspect:

1. The Israeli protesters against Netanyahu will continue to protest as they have conflated their animus for Bibi with the separate issue of the war strategy.

2. International pressure and Jew hatred will be unchanged as they were planned and activated by October 8th before Israel fought back in Gaza.

3. Saudi Arabia will do what is best for Saudi Arabia, independent of a cease fire; they don't care about Gaza. They do know that in the Arab world, any show of conciliation is seen as weakness. They want a strong Israel as an ally against a threatening Iran.

4. With no change in Palestinian thinking, and the release of terrorists from Israeli jails, there will be no change in their age-old call for Jewish and Israeli annihilation. further 10/7s, and definitely more hostage taking. Israel was fooled once with the Shalit trade; they shouldn't be fooled again. Jewish principles about the redemption of hostages is long standing. However, the unmentioned part of that teaching is that the ransom can't be excessive, as it presents a win for kidnappers and entices them to do it again. Truly wise Israeli soldiers sometimes write a "no ransom" letter before going into battle. I think they understand their enemy, history, and, human nature. You can't compromise or reason in the hell of war with an unrelenting, purely evil enemy that is sworn to your destruction. Accomodation only benefits Hamas and its supporters, not Israel, not Jews worldwide, and not even the Gazans.

Expand full comment
Sully Bemak's avatar

Bibi should do the opposite of whatever Biden recommends.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts